COLUMN: Think Again – Clear thinking about Israel and Hamas
Advertisement
Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 05/04/2024 (961 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.
It’s been nearly six months since Hamas carried out its deadly Oct. 7 terrorist attacks against Israel. On that day, more than 1,200 Israelis were brutally murdered and approximately 240 were taken hostage by Hamas terrorists.
In response, Israel declared war on Hamas and launched a series of military strikes on the Gaza strip. While Canadian prime minister Justin Trudeau initially expressed solidarity with Israel, deep divisions in the Liberal caucus have caused his government to equivocate on that support.
Last month, the NDP used its opposition day in the House of Commons to introduce a motion recognizing a Palestinian state. At the last minute, the Liberals and NDP agreed on a series of amendments that watered down the original motion enough so that all but a handful of Liberal MPs could support it.
The fact that the House of Commons would spend an entire day debating a motion that rewards an explicitly genocidal government for carrying out a series of brutal terrorist attacks is a sign of how muddled our country’s foreign affairs policy has become. Now more than ever, we need clear thinking on this issue.
Fortunately, retired philosopher Dr. Hendrik van der Breggen has a new book out that is a must-read for anyone who wants to think critically about this topic. In Untangling Popular Anti-Israel Arguments, Dr. van der Breggen dispels many of the most common myths and false assumptions about the Israel/Hamas conflict.
For example, Israel’s critics frequently claim that Israel is engaging in genocide against the Palestinians. However, Dr. van der Breggen reminds his readers that it was Hamas that started this war. If Hamas really cared about the Palestinian people, they would never have intentionally slaughtered 1,200 Israeli civilians on October 7, something they knew would provoke a severe military response from Israel.
Dr. van der Breggen also argues that intent matters in military conflicts. While Hamas intentionally targeted civilians on Oct. 7 and uses women and children as human shields to maximize civilian casualties, Israel tries to avoid hitting civilian targets and warns Palestinian civilians to evacuate before engaging in a bombing campaign. Civilian casualties are always tragic but there is a clear distinction between how Hamas and Israel conduct themselves on this matter.
Another common claim is that Israel’s response to Hamas has not been proportional. Critics regularly point to the lopsided casualty statistics and argue that since far more Palestinians than Israelis have been killed in the last six months, Israel is acting unjustly in its response.
However, Dr. van der Breggen points out that no other country has been held to this type of standard. The notion that since Hamas terrorists killed approximately 1,200 Israelis on October 7 Israel must make sure it kills exactly 1,200 Palestinians in response is ridiculous. Under this reasoning, Israel should target a border village and rape the same number of women that Hamas terrorists raped, kill the same number of babies targeted by Hamas, and burn an equivalent number of Palestinian families alive in their own homes.
Israel is at war with Hamas because it is seeking to eliminate that terrorist group’s ability to carry out further terrorist attacks. Not only is that a worthwhile goal, but it is also the only acceptable outcome from this conflict. It is awful that Hamas is choosing to extend this conflict by refusing to surrender and release their hostages, but that is the fault of Hamas, not Israel.
Anyone interested in clear thinking about the Israel/Hamas conflict should get a copy of Dr. van der Breggen’s book. There is far too much muddled reasoning about this issue in Canada today.
Michael Zwaagstra is a high school teacher and a Steinbach city councillor. He can be reached at mzwaagstra@shaw.ca.