COLUMN: On Parliament Hill – Bill C-41: Two very different questions, one dangerous bill

Advertisement

Advertise with us

Few issues are more important than the dignity and value of human life. That is why Bill C-41 deserves our careful attention. It is deeply unfortunate that the Liberal government packaged two fundamentally different questions about Medical Assistance in Dying (MAID) into the same bill, creating a difficult moral dilemma for many parliamentarians.

By the time this is published, if all goes as the Liberal government hopes, the vote will have taken place, and because they have a majority government, the bill will have passed. Had the two issues been separated and debated independently, things could have been very different.

Only weeks ago, just minutes before the House was scheduled to vote on Bill C-218—a bill that would have reversed the 2021 Senate amendment and permanently excluded mental illness as the sole underlying condition to qualify for Medical Assistance in Dying (MAID)—the Justice Minister announced the government’s intention to introduce its own legislation.

The controversial addition to the new bill to allow MAID through advance requests means that MAID can be administered based on a request made years earlier, while the individual is still “competent”.

The debate raises fundamentally different questions about consent, human dignity and the value of life.

One of those questions is: how can we truly know what our future selves will want?

Some parliamentarians shared heart-tugging stories of loved ones who lived with dementia and Alzheimer’s disease. One story concerned former deputy leader of the Official Opposition Lisa Raitt, whose husband Bruce faced advancing dementia, requiring her to move Bruce into full-time care. In a recent public post, Lisa questioned whether, if Bruce made the decision for MAID, would she have been the deciding factor for its administration. She concluded that while Bruce is a different man today than before, he remains content and comfortable, and she would ultimately feel compelled to ignore any advance request if it were in effect.

But Lisa raises the critical question: Who gets to decide whether another person’s life is still worth living?

An oncologist responding to the discussion made a similar observation. He said that someone could be laughing, enjoying life and finding meaning in their days, all while an outside observer might judge the quality of their life very differently. Without the benefit of future experiences, how can anyone make an irreversible decision about a life they have yet to live?

The absence of a person’s voice at the critical point of administration creates serious risk.

What one imagines into the future rarely unfolds exactly as one might expect. So how can anyone anticipate exactly how they will feel or what they’ll experience in the future? Think about when you became a parent, when you met the love of your life, when you overcame a health scare or achieved a lifelong ambition. Did reaching that milestone result in exactly what you imagined?

Consider what this means. The person who signed the document is not the person receiving the injection. One was writing in a moment of fear about the future. The other is a person, a human being living in the present, perhaps confused, perhaps frail, perhaps still laughing with the grandchildren or enjoying a song. Which person is the doctor supposed to listen to?

Circumstances change. Priorities evolve. New treatments emerge. Experiences reshape understanding.

Inclusion Canada has also warned that decisions about MAID could be influenced by discriminatory assumptions about disability, dependence and quality of life. A person’s need for assistance should never become a measure of whether their life is worth living.

Similarly, Dementia Justice Canada has raised concerns about undue influence, coercive control and abuse. It questions how practitioners can reliably determine whether a person’s words, sounds or gestures amount to a refusal of MAID, and whether repeated attempts to administer it could eventually lead someone to stop resisting.

These concerns are not isolated. In 2025, the United Nations Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities called on Canada not to expand MAID to include advance requests.

From my faith perspective, I believe God holds the key to life. Every season and stage of life has value because we are made in the image of God. Beyond matters of faith, Canada must confront the serious ethical and practical questions this legislation raises.

Ultimately, Bill C-41 asks whether a document signed today should authorize someone’s death years later, when they can no longer communicate, reconsider or withdraw that decision.

Maintaining the exclusion of MAID where mental illness is the sole underlying medical condition is an important safeguard. Expanding MAID through advance requests is an entirely different matter, with profound consequences.

The government should never have forced Parliament to choose between the two.

I could not support Bill C-41 as presented. The two provisions needed to be separated and, sadly, weren’t.

We can be a country that protects the vulnerable or one that finds ever more efficient ways to make them disappear. I choose to care. And I choose to stand beside every Canadian, in every stage of life, and say: “You matter, I choose life.”

Report Error Submit a Tip

Local

LOAD LOCAL ARTICLES