LETTER TO THE EDITOR: From enlightenment to endarkenment

Advertisement

Advertise with us

As Charles Dickens reflected in the opening sentence of A Tale of Two Cities, “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness … it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair…”

Dickens’ epic novel was set in the tumultuous period leading up to and during the French Revolution, known as the 18th century Age of Enlightenment. Built on the scientific revolution of the 16th and 17th centuries, the Enlightenment prioritized reason and empirical evidence, and promoted ideals of natural rights, individual liberty, social equality, representative government, and the rule of law.

It thereby undermined both traditional absolute monarchy and religious authority, provoking political revolutions in the 19th and 20th centuries ranging from liberalism to socialism. Denying that society was pre-ordained, the Enlightenment embraced the possibility of progress, not the resignation of fatalism, and generated hope.

But come the 21st century, those lights are dimming, and hope is fading. Indeed, we have now entered what has been termed the Age of Endarkenment. Not a return to the pre-Enlightenment era of the Early Middle or “Dark Ages,” a term now deprecated by most historians, it is instead a turn to a neo-Dark Age.

In his illuminating essay on Endarkenment, Martin Gurri defines it as “an age of delusion, impossible longings, and ritual self-mutilation, [that] rises, like an accusing specter, out of the corpse of the fallen Enlightenment.” It is the apocalyptic doom of nihilistic meaninglessness rendered by both the reality of devastating facts and the disreality of alternative facts.

Ecologically, the industrial revolution, catalysed by the scientific revolution and championed by the Enlightenment, has so degraded the earth that we now inhabit the geological age of the Anthropocene, where human activity is the dominant force shaping earth’s climate and environment, leaving irreversible damage.

Technologically, modern tools have now also threatened all humanity with annihilation via nuclear warfare. More recently, they have delivered artificial intelligence which may surpass and displace human intelligence in dark ways to the point where we no longer need to fear how humans have long dehumanized each other, but instead dread the erasure of humanity altogether.

Furthermore, the digital technologies of social media and generative AI algorithms have empowered not merely mis-information, but dis-information, and even mal-information. Tragically, in the context of post-modernism, they create a post-truth, post-moral, pure power cultural ethos, accelerating the erosion of public trust in social institutions, and the deep political divides that weaken social cohesion.

Politically, the escalation of authoritarian populism, if not (yet?) totalitarian fascism, has reversed the democratic revolution propelled by Enlightenment principles during “democracy’s century.” In 1900, three percent of the world’s population lived in democratic states, in 2000 it was 53 percent, but today it is 29 percent.

Economically, the return of unfettered neo-liberal capitalism concurrent with the retreat of the welfare state over the past 50 years has produced social stratification reminiscent of medieval aristocracy. Today, the richest one percent of the world’s population own 46 percent of its wealth, while the poorest 55 percent own one percent of its wealth.

Socially, recent data document the drastic decline in both the quantity and quality of personal friendships, as well as civic engagement in voluntary associations, resulting in the rapid rise of social isolation and mental illness – surging rates of loneliness, anxiety, and depression, particularly among youth.

One common consequence of these multiple aspects of Endarkenment is escalating denialism, the rejection of undisputed scientific facts or historical records to protect self-interest or avoid uncomfortable truths. Prominent examples include denial of human-induced climate change, the residential school system, institutional racism, sexual diversity, biomedical consensus, or election results, all often driven by conspiracy theories.

Disconcertingly, rates of denialism are also correlated with the political spectrum, being more prevalent on the right.

Just as Dylan Thomas implored his dying father in the closing line of his epic poem Do Not Go Gentle into that Good Night, we too must collectively “Rage, rage against the dying of the light.” As for hope in this darkening age, Leonard Cohen sang inspiringly that “There is a crack, a crack in everything; that’s how the light gets in.”

Perhaps the latest U.S. mid-term elections were one such crack.

Report Error Submit a Tip

Local

LOAD LOCAL ARTICLES