COLUMN: Think Again – Don’t be fooled by Wab Kinew
Advertisement
A provincial election is coming soon. Premier Wab Kinew has dropped plenty of hints that it will happen this spring, probably right after his government tables its annual budget.
Expect that budget to contain plenty of goodies. Not only will it contain some big-ticket spending items and grandiose promises, but it’s also likely going to be balanced, at least on paper.
However, don’t be fooled.
If Kinew does manage to balance the budget, it won’t be because of prudent fiscal management. Rather, it will be due to a combination of higher federal transfer payments and some creative accounting tricks.
For example, Kinew’s government recently decided to include money in the Workers’ Compensation Board (WCB) fund as part of its annual budget. This fund is paid for by businesses and is set aside for workers. At any given time, the WCB fund could have tens of millions of dollars in it since payments depend on the number of claims made by injured workers.
Importantly, the WCB fund cannot be used by the government for general expenditures. Thus, the only reason to include this money in the provincial budget is to artificially inflate the size of provincial revenues. It’s an obvious accounting trick, and Manitobans should not be fooled by it.
During a recent press conference at his party’s annual convention, Kinew said that his government has reached the limit of what it can do to help with affordability. At first glance, this might sound like an acknowledgement that gimmicks like removing the PST from pop and chips in grocery stores or temporarily lifting the provincial gas tax before putting it right back up aren’t having the desired impact.
Frankly, Kinew’s comment reminds me of the famous Simpsons line, “We’ve tried nothing and we’re all out of ideas.” That’s because there’s one really obvious thing Kinew can do to improve affordability for Manitobans—let us keep more of our own money.
As the Progressive Conservatives have proposed, the best way to do this would be to raise the basic personal exemption on income tax to $30,000. This would save a typical two-income family of four more than $3,000 on their taxes every year. I suspect an extra $3,000 in their pockets would improve affordability for most Manitoba families.
However, Kinew won’t do this. Rather, he says that it’s time for big corporations to do more to help Manitobans out. In other words, Kinew wants to raise business taxes so that his government can spend more on social programs. The problem with this approach is that higher corporate taxes will simply lead to corporations deciding that Manitoba isn’t a good place to do business and invest elsewhere instead.
Interestingly, federal NDP leader Avi Lewis was a keynote speaker at the Manitoba NDP convention. Lewis won the federal NDP leadership by running on a far-left platform. Not only does Lewis want to jack up corporate tax rates, but Lewis also proposes to leave natural resources in the ground. In addition, Lewis thinks the time has come for government-run grocery stores, which is the kind of failed socialist proposal that belongs in the dustbin of history.
The provincial NDP leaders in Alberta and Saskatchewan at least have enough sense to distance themselves from Lewis and the federal NDP. In contrast, Kinew has chosen to embrace Lewis, which means we can brace ourselves for Kinew to follow Lewis’s example in his next term.
Don’t let Wab Kinew’s rosy promises fool you. If he gets another term in office, Manitoba is going to become an even more have-not province than it is now.
We cannot let that happen.
Michael Zwaagstra is a teacher, former deputy mayor of Steinbach, and the PC candidate for the Steinbach Constituency. He can be reached at mzwaagstra@shaw.ca.